日本語
Soccer Laws Dojo

Judge DB

2023 J1 Promotion Play-off Final Tokyo Verdy vs Shimizu S-Pulse

[Penalty Kick] A borderline sliding tackle inside the penalty area

An original analysis of real match footage.

Final Decision

Penalty Kick

Close call Controversial

A Tokyo Verdy player broke into the penalty area and was stopped by a sliding tackle from a Shimizu S-Pulse player. The referee judged it to be a foul and awarded a penalty kick.

Referee Review

Why was this decision made?

See the key points from a referee’s perspective

Show explanation

How the footage and Laws apply

Whether the slide was a fair challenge is the central question here, and this was an extremely difficult incident to judge. In the footage, the defending player from Shimizu slides towards the ball, but appears to make contact with the left leg of the Tokyo Verdy attacking player before touching the ball. At the same time, the attacking player also appears to put their left leg out towards the defender, blocking their path. The referee on the field judged this split-second entanglement to be a foul and awarded a penalty kick. The contact is close enough that an offence by either player could be argued, and it is a highly demanding decision that generated considerable debate.

Relevant Laws

Law 12 - Fouls and Misconduct

Official references

Check the wording of the Laws

The links above lead to official IFAB and JFA resources. The application of the Laws to this incident is the author’s analysis and is not an official view of IFAB, JFA or the competition organiser.

Want to test your understanding of this decision?

Build confidence with more Laws of the Game questions in the app.

Try more questions in the app

Related Scenes